I have heard it about all the shoe clubs, ShoeDazzle, ShoeMint, SoleSociety, and JustFab. People say the shoes are cheaply made and lack quality.
I cannot advise on the other clubs because, although I have purchased from them, I don’t purchase continually (like I do with JustFab shoes).
To me, one of the key elements of quality is durability. Things built for quality last a long time, even when used a lot. So I decided on buying a pair of JustFab shoes (actually boots) to run them through the paces. I had help, my niece wears the same size as I do and when I wasn’t wearing the boots, she, more than likely, was.
I picked Jola (bootie) as my guinea pig. High heels would take a lot longer to test as I usually only wear high heels for a span of 2-4 hours at a time and I wanted something both me and my niece could tolerate wearing all day.
We ran these booties through the ringer. I wore them at work all day. I walked several miles in them during a local wine crawl and Ice sculpture event. They never got a break (except when they were in the trunk of my car for a few days).
I gave them to my niece and she wore them to school for two weeks straight.
These boots experienced hard concrete, snow, mud, and more.
We both think the boots were comfortable and they held up like troopers. So to all the haters who scream about shoe club shoes being cheaply made and junk, explain this: This picture is of JustFab’s Jola bootie after four weeks of continuous wear and downright abuse. No TLC what so ever. We didn’t even wipe the winter salt off with a cloth.